"Whenever I go into a restaurant, I order both a chicken and an egg to see which comes first"

Friday, September 7, 2018

The Futility Of Retrieving Old Loves–The Tragic Story Of John Updike’s Rabbit Angstrom

Outside the sealed hospital windows, in the slowly thickening dusk, sap is rising, and the air even in here feels languid with pollen.  Involuntarily Harry’s eyes close again. “No”, he says, “that’s OK. Don’t tell her anything. I doubt if she’d remember anything.”  He is suddenly tired, too tired for Ruth.  Even if the girl is his daughter, it’s an old story, going on and on, like a radio nobody’s listening to (Rabbit at Rest)

Image result for images rabbit at rest updike

Harry Angstrom has just met the young woman who might be his daughter, the child of a woman he knew years ago but never forgotten.  Their affair had been brief – a solace, a comfortable place, and a refuge from the deaths and unhappiness of a family he never wanted, resented, and corrupted.  He never regretted his life, as difficult and inescapable as it was; refused to feel guilty, remorseful, or self-pitying; and went on with a life that he knew was suffocating and infuriating.  He knew that had one or two things turned out differently he might have made his way out of the poor Pennsylvania mill town where he grew up, might have never had to repeat his father’s miserable working life, and never – caught between Midwestern sobriety and religion and ambition – had to marry or live a life ordered and controlled by others of such bad taste and no inspiration.

Image result for images western pennsylvania depressed town

Yet he never forgot Ruth, who might or might not be the mother of his daughter, and who might still be the same savior she had been then, someone to give him some hope that life had at least some glimmer of reason and possibility and not the depressing, short, and ugly life he had been given and worse accepted.  He sees her again but has forgotten her resentment and her anger at Harry’s facile engagement – the husband who will go back to his wife.  Harry knew nothing of her own difficult marriage and poor life, and assumed that she would be as willing as he to restart their friendship.  She had become in light of his impending death, far more than she ever was and nothing she could ever really be. 

The story is familiar.  There is nothing new about middle-aged men who look up former lovers.  After divorce, that is the first place they go and the first place of disappointment.  Old lovers have gotten fat, married, and as irrevocably married to disappointing men and mother of disappointing children and as dispirited as they had been.  Better never to look.

Harry, however, does look; but despite his damaged, increasingly hopeless life, he never gives in.  He never hopes for any resolve or anything better, but is still defiantly alive.  There is something valuable there, even inviolable – despite the absurdity of a 250 lb. soggy body; a mess of fouled arteries and failing organs; and the few signs of beauty, charm, or appeal wherever he looks.  He has become mean-spirited, angry, and bullying; but he is uncontrite.  His son’s addiction, his wife’s cluelessness, his spoiled grandchildren, the depressing life of a Florida condo and an old Rust Belt town deserve to be yelled at.  None of this has anything to do with him – they are circumstantial and peripheral.  His lack of compassion and refusal to understand and compromise are not products of his deformity but theirs.  And in fact he is far more intelligent, far more aware, and far more courageous than anyone around him – family, friends, and co-workers that he did not choose but were chosen for him.  There can be no American dream if the cards are dealt before you learn the game.

Image result for images florida condos

Despite his angry misanthropy, his refusal to accept the hand he was dealt, and his inability to move past the events that have forced him unwillingly but as a direct result of his actions, he is still a sympathetic character.  We forgive his brief moments of out-of-character idealism because he has had so little of it.  Nothing has offered either promise or reward since his days as a high-school basketball star.  He was as lured by the American Dream as anyone, and as let down by an unforgiving, immobile life as everyone else.

His moments of self-pity and idealism do not last; and Harry, after seeing Ruth, reverts to his old self; but realizes and accepts his coming death as a welcome end.  There is no room for his kind of humanity, his absolute defiance and insistence on integrity and individual expression.  He was irrepressible in his youth (Rabbit Run, Rabbit Redux) – dangerously so, unwilling to see how his ambition and selfish needs could and did hurt others.  Deaths were on his hands.  Yet he neither shied away from his responsibility for them, although he was only indirectly liable, nor let them wear down his spirit and his conviction of worth and value.

He dies as he began – on a basketball court, as arrogantly defiant of the odds as he ever was, refusing to live out his life meticulously and to see the last juices of his absolute will dribble out unnoticed by anyone.  Harry is an unlikely hero, but a hero nonetheless.  His suicide – for that is inescapably what it is – is not an act of desperation, but defiance.  A refusal to be neutered, laid down, and forgotten as a man.  Even sleeping with his son’s wife - for which he was never apologetic and which was as in character as his final game in the slums of Deleon – was not enough of an anodyne for his hopelessness.

Harry would never have even used the word.  Life for him was never hopeless, but simply a given.  He had the right to see something beyond it, an almost spiritual, faithless, but accurate perception of the way things are and will always be.  Hope was meaningless.  Acceptance was worse.  Only defiance in the name of living mattered.

The men who look for lost loves are no Harrys.  They have none of his will nor his absolute refusal to give in.  Unanchored dreams, a brief respite from the wife, memories which have been reconfigured and transformed into something that might have been but probably never was.  Time and emotional penury distort all memory.

The difference between Harry and men looking for an impossible past is that he never had any regrets.  He did not regret that he deceived Ruth or never loved Thelma – the only woman who truly, inexplicably, but resolutely loved him until her death – nor did he rethink his relationships with his wife.  It could never have been otherwise, as inexorable in its trajectory as any.  Had Ruth turned out to still love him; and had her daughter really been his, then perhaps the death of his own daughter and the drunken hands of his wife might be forgiven; and his own inexplicable but necessary long marriage to her finally put to rest; but the reality was not unexpected.  Life had never been promising, so why should it be now?

Harry was insufferable to his son and to his grandchildren – selfish, impatient, and intolerant – and it is easy, especially in today’s climate of a hoped-for loving fatherhood, to criticize him for it.  Yet we cannot blame him because their own selfish and spoiled natures were not his fault, but simply products of a life which held more selfishness than generosity.   It is not easy to love Harry, but we can.

Rabbit at Rest is a moving, unforgettable story of a common man who was less common than anyone around him.

Monday, September 3, 2018

A Cynic’s View Of First Love

F. Scott Fitzgerald wrote that there are many kinds of love in the world, but never the same love twice. Harley Ferguson was not angry or even disappointed at the way things had turned out.  He had married Martha and chosen the tried and true because his love for Bickford, his first wife,  had stressed his emotional halyards to the breaking point.  No one can live such a precarious sexual and fundamentally passionate life for too long.  Winds change, sails luff, and courses are reset for home.

Image result for images f scott fitzgerald

As he grew older Harley was resigned to the years he had spent with Martha.  A stable relationship; happy, successful children; and the promise of innocence and heritage in grandchildren were nothing to sniff at. Yet he could never forget Bickford. How could he have divorced her? How could he have ignored the fundamental – no, existential – relationship between them? Youth, perhaps and certainly. Ignorance? Even obtuseness? Probably since no one expects wisdom when young. What, then?

There were many things that Harley wished to shake from his memory – failed loves, idiocy, stupid remarks, cowardliness – but he knew that the bitter-sweet, lovely, and often painful trace of Bickford was there forever. A sentinel perhaps even in his old age. A beacon.  Love does exist, but never the same love twice.

The hardest thing was not the forgetting, the filing away of seminal memories, the relegation of love to an unrecoverable past; but dealing with the decision.  How, he wondered in his later years, had he been so intimidated?  How could he have curled up, snuggled into a relationship of predictability and good sense when his life had been correctly navigated from port? What was it about himself that he had tried, quite unsuccessfully as it turned out, to hide?

Months before their final decision to divorce, Harley had gone to Bickford and said that he was willing to live her way – off any social grid, far from the Fathers of St. Maurice, even farther from the prayers and solicitude of New Brighton.  She could have been brought up anywhere or nowhere, a woman of unheard of sexual and emotional liberty; a woman who, despite her own nuns, priests, and Midwest piety, was having none of it; who elided with the Andy Warhol generation without preparation, ambition, forethought, or concern.  It was in her blood; in her genes; and Harvey had no idea whom he was marrying.

Image result for andy warhol velvet underground

On the surface she was the ideal match – similar education, solid bourgeois, respectable family; beautiful, smart, talented, and ambitious but within acceptable borders – but who knew what was percolating up and out?  How the bits of Victorian libertine Hubert de Villiers’ genetic code got caught in her wires; or how she inherited some of  her father’s truculence – he was always thought obstinate and disagreeable, but he had a niggardly defiance of imposed social borders - or her grandmother’s well-kept secret passion for young boys?

In other words he had no idea who he was marrying but was naively satisfied with the image – the respectable, status-well image of certain success.

He fell impossibly in love with her; and even discounting the fact that she was his first love, it was something else – part Petrarch, part chivalric ode, part Hollywood romance, part Romeo and Juliet, part Shakespeare's sonnets to his young man, and part some indescribable late adolescent longing for intimacy, womanhood, and sexual security.

Romantic Love
with the name that Love wrote on my heart,
the sound of its first sweet accents begin
to be heard within the word laudable.
Your regal state, that I next encounter,
doubles my power for the high attempt;
but: ‘Tacit’, the ending cries, ‘since to do her honor
is for other men’s shoulders, not for yours’.
So, whenever one calls out to you,
the voice itself teaches us to Laud, Revere,
you, O, lady worthy of all reverence and honor:
except perhaps that Apollo is disdainful
that mortal tongue can be so presumptuous
as to speak of his eternally green branches.
Petrarch
After the divorce and the quick second marriage, Harley did his best to accommodate to his new life and new wife.  He felt he could finally take a breath – she would always be there in the evening, in bed with him by nine; up, positive, spirited, and calm by eight.  She was all equilibrium, an ultimate evening out of the electromagnetic spikes and troughs of his first marriagre.  If there was no drama or even melodrama; if there were no ups and downs, nothing unpredictable, no surprises, and no guesswork; so be it.  He had signed on for a life of smooth sailing and had left Scylla and Charybdis far behind.

See the source image

Yet as the years with Martha progressed – predictably, uneventfully, and uninterrupted; and as even an amateur psychologist would have surmised, protected by a well-constructed cynical defense against the self-recriminatory, often painful memories of his divorce from a woman he loved.  Marriage – or any prescribed institutional relationship for that matter – was fiction and no more than a confection made up of old feelings for Mommy or Daddy, Hollywood, the Catholic Fathers, and social imperium.  There was no such thing as love, let alone the over-Hallmarked, soap opera version of it.  Love was a matter of convention, an appendix of economic necessity overlaid with romantic idealism.

As marriages age, he concluded, they become little more than private institutions providing social and emotional support.  Easier to rely on a partner with whom one has lived for fifty years than on the vicissitudes of the State.

What to make, then, of romantic pictures of 80-somethings walking on the beach? Do they still love each other after all those years? Mutual dependency is a kind of love after all; and there is every reason to avoid any chance of dissension or disagreement and jeopardize the arrangement.  Holding hands is the visible sign of an operational contract.

Image result for images old people holding hands on the beach

He persisted in this notion for years, content with his wife’s monogamy, his desultory love affairs, his grandchildren, and his uninterrupted trajectory.  He never, until much later in life even admitted that he might have been wrong – not just wrong in divorcing Bickford, but in dismissing the idea of love and especially first love.  Hard though it was to admit, Petrarch and the Shakespeare of the Sonnets might well be right.

There was peril in opening this particular chest.  Admitting that he had not only given up his one and only chance for a truly fulfilled life – one that was consistent with his personality, character, and ambition – and admitting that there was indeed something that he had both missed and missed out upon – could be very painful.  One would need a lot of nihilism and resolve to look therein and be able to look away with some measure of equanimity.

He did look finally.  He revisited their early years, their church marriage, their short life together, and their divorce; but as much as he tried to relegate these memories to memory, he could not.  He had loved her, had always loved her, and had loved no one but her. His life since their separation had been deceitful, and dishonest – not dishonest in itself since he had respected convention and propriety to a large degree – but dishonest in essence. 

After so long it was hard to give up his cynical persona – his quotes from Albee, Shakespeare, and O’Neill, his social economics (‘The Contractual Basis of Marriage’), and his growing indifference about home affairs and, as Patricia Highsmith put it in ‘The Talented Mr. Ripley’, ‘Marge maintenance’ – satisfying the spouse.  How could he revert to first love idealism when his first love was long dead and buried?  How could he admit to a life of second best satisfaction?

He never did admit it nor anything like it to anyone.  It would remain a personal error, one among many.  Besides, there were too many sunken costs in his forty-some year marriage.  Why give it even the slightest jostle, especially from a long forgotten – except for him – past?

Harley the romantic and Harley the cynic never reached an agreement or a settlement; and of course that was Harley’s consignment, his fate.  He would think of Bickford until his dying breath; but where did that ever get him?

Saturday, September 1, 2018

The Doctrine Of Grave Sin And Hell–Has Sin Become Too Explainable, Too Easily Dismissed, Forgiven, And Overlooked?

There was a time not long ago when a mortal sin, without expiation or pardon, would consign the sinner to eternal damnation – not only the fiery Hell of popular legend, but worse, an eternity deprived of the sight of God.  Because Christ’s message was one of forgiveness and redemption, even mortal sins could be pardoned; but only if the sinner confessed honestly and with conviction promising never to sin again.

Most children of that earlier era never questioned this punitive/redemptive message.  A mortal sin was to be avoided, for even the promising life of a young man filled with opportunity, risk, faith, and forgiveness could be in jeopardy.  It was a simple faith.  One did not only sin against oneself and one’s immortal soul, but sin against God himself.  A state of grace – an interlude between forgiveness and the next sin -  was a contract between Creator and obedient servant.  Sin was an offense against both parties; forgiveness came from God himself.  The contract was holy, binding, and permanent.

According to Catholic teaching, perfect contrition, coupled with a firm resolution to sin no more, can restore a person's relationship with God, as well as God's saving grace. Under ordinary circumstances this takes place through absolution, which is received during the Sacrament of Penance. However, as God's mercy and forgiveness is not bound by the Sacrament of Penance, under extraordinary circumstances a mortal sin can be remitted through perfect contrition, which is a human act that arises from a person's love of God.[2] When perfect contrition is the means by which one seeks to restore ones relationship with God, there must also be a resolution to confess all mortal sins (that have not been confessed and absolved previously) in the Sacrament of Penance. A resolution to confess these sins should be made with an act of perfect contrition, regardless of whether or not a person believes that they will have access to the Sacrament of Penance.

Image result for images confession medieval

As children grew into adolescence and young adulthood, the equation lost its simplicity.  How could a beneficent, loving God consign anyone to an eternity of hellfire for natural, predictable human failings? Was there not something illogical about consignment to the same circle of Hell for murder and sexual infidelity? Were not many Biblical injunctions only orders to keep the faith, to maintain spiritual integrity, and to respect the Divinity; and if so, how could their disrespect be equated with life’s true horrors?

By the time these young Catholics grew up, they found themselves maturing in an age of relativism.  Not only was morality culturally determined but the concept of sin itself outmoded, medieval, and irrelevant.  Hell was a mythological place designed by and insisted upon by the ambitious senior clergy of the Church to assure allegiance, fealty, and obedience.  There was no such thing, no such place; and even metaphorically the whole idea of eternal anything was melodrama and fiction.

The Church has three criteria for mortal sin:

  1. Its subject matter must be grave.
  2. It must be committed with full knowledge (and awareness) of the sinful action and the gravity of the offense.
  3. It must be committed with deliberate and complete consent.

Although these criteria seem reasonable, giving every sinner a chance to reflect, to decide, and to act on his own – all consistent with Christ’s message of free will and individual destiny – they contain the seeds of discontent, rebellion, and disbelief within them. Who is to decide if a matter is grave?  The Vatican whose morality, although postulated as absolute, is as subject to culture and the times as any? The Bible, whose moral standards as expressed in the New Testament are appeals from an early form of ex cathedra statement?  The modern Vatican under siege because of its archaic stance on commonly accepted practices of behavior? Contraception is, in the eyes of the Church, a serious crime not because of its practical influence, but because of its denial of the supremacy and authority of God.  Such theological parsing, while logical and rational a la Aquinas, Augustine, and Tertullian means little to the 21st century Catholic, influenced by the persuasive rhetoric of women’s, civil, and individual rights.  Contraception cannot possibly be sinful, given its clear and unchallenged benefits to women.

Abortion, too, falls within this modernist, progressive relativistic ambit.  Abortion in an overpopulated, questionably moral, predatory, and harsh world is not only a statement for a women’s right to choose but for world progress.

Even the most heinous of crimes and most serious injunction of the Ten Commandments – murder – is parsed and contextualized.  Killing can be justified in ever more understandable ways.  When considered within the perspective of the injustices of race, gender, and ethnicity, killing can be righteous.  Killing in righteous wars is justified.  Capital punishment in the most unforgiveable cases, is permitted.

The recent cases of clerical sexual abuse in the Catholic Church demand not only civil prosecution and removal from religious authority, but a look at something far more important – the nature of sin, the Catholic version of it, and modern versions of morality.  When Jesus said, "Let the little children come to me, and do not hinder them, for the kingdom of heaven belongs to such as these." (Matthew 19:4), it was a universal injunction, one which noted the innocence of children, their special beauty and meaning, and the absolute need to protect them.  To harm them, to endanger them, to compromise their beauty and their future was the most mortal of sins.  Unforgiveable, unpardonable, and irrefutable.

TOLES PRIESTS

It is bad enough for parents, guardians, and teachers to abuse their children; but ordained, anointed representatives of Christ on earth? Dostoevsky reflects on this inhumanity in The Brothers Karamazov:

A poor child of five was subjected to every possible torture by those cultivated parents. They beat her, thrashed her, kicked her for no reason till her body was one bruise. Then, they went to greater refinements of cruelty -- shut her up all night in the cold and frost in a privy, and because she didn't ask to be taken up at night (as though a child of five sleeping its angelic, sound sleep could be trained to wake and ask), they smeared her face and filled her mouth with excrement, and it was her mother, her mother did this. And that mother could sleep, hearing the poor child's groans! Can you understand why a little creature, who can't even understand what's done to her, should beat her little aching heart with her tiny fist in the dark and the cold, and weep her meek unresentful tears to dear, kind God to protect her? Do you understand that, friend and brother, you pious and humble novice?
Image result for images the grand inquisitor

This inhumanity, this abuse, this spiritual neglect was at the hands of peasants.  What can be said then of abuse by those who should know better and who, as ordained and anointed representatives of Christ on earth, are charged with the protection of children?

Dante wrote of the circles of Hell, and the Ninth, the last, was for the most irremediably sinful.  All residents are frozen in an icy lake, and those who committed more severe sin are deeper within the ice – Cain who killed his brother Abel and Judas Iscariot the apostle who betrayed Jesus with a kiss.  Certainly abusive priests belong in the Ninth Circle.

Treachery

Then what to make of the current crisis of sexual abuse in the Catholic Church?

Do Cardinal McCarrick and many others in the clergy believe in retribution? Do they believe in the eternal separation of hell? If they accept hell in theory, do they believe in its actual possibility for unrepentant sinners who persist in mortal sin? Is there, for them, such a thing as mortal sin—or are our lives about choosing a “fundamental option” for God that assures eternal blessedness regardless of our thoughts, words, and deeds? (First Things).

Pope John Paul II rejected any notion of moral arbitrariness:

There are “intrinsically evil acts” that “radically contradict the good of the person made in God’s image,” wrote the pope. “They are [evil] always and per se.”

If John Paul II is right, then the Church has no recourse except to banish them.  Yet banishment is not enough.  Pope Francis must call the abusive priests to task in a way which invokes the fundamental Christian concept of good and evil.  He should not only dismiss them as any executive might fire an employee for non-performance or failure to adhere to company policy, but hold them up as a penitential example of sin, corruption, and moral evil.  Their sin was mortal, unconscionable, and a complete dereliction moral, spiritual, and contractual responsibility.

Image result for images john paul ii

What, then, does this all mean for the rest of us? Has our evolution into a relativist, amoral, and secular society endangered us? Has progressivism, with its focus on temporal progress, achievement, and values clouded our moral judgment?  Is there really no right or wrong, no absolute, and most importantly no divine judge?

If the Church ignores the abusive clerics, denies their consignment to the Ninth Circle of Hell, and uses the doctrines of forgiveness and redemption as a perennial cover for the complete dereliction of duty and an insult to Christ himself, they will never recover.

A complete, forthright, honest act of contrition will not only save the Church but will be a resonant and long-overdue message for the rest of us.