Marfa Potter never met a beggar she passed by. The indignity, the raw insult of perpetual poverty, the inhumanity of poverty amidst plenty! She gave to the homeless man with the sign, WILL WORK FOR FOOD', the Metro Station blind man holding the hand of his young daughter who held out her hands in supplication, the destitute man huddled in a pile of newspapers to keep warm, the mentally vacant, the old men pushing shopping carts.
'I wish I could do more', she said, emptying her pockets for Henry, the homeless man wandering from one bench to the other on Farragut Square, a downtown park not far from the White House. This was America's worst, most unpardonable sin - letting the destitute, the abandoned suffer when the most powerful man in the world feasted on pheasant and foie gras.
There were so many destitute and homeless in Washington that Melissa had developed a triage. She couldn't attend to the needs of each and every one, for there were hundreds, sleeping on heated grates, in makeshift shelters under overpasses, up and down Fourteenth Street, and panhandling on lawyer lane, the famous K Street corridor of lobbyists, trial attorneys, land development lawyers, and real estate advisers.
The difference could not be more stark - the glitterati making their way down Pennsylvania Avenue to the White House, beautiful blue-eyed blonde interns, Congressional aides, or executive assistants and the forgotten begging for spare change along the way.
The Armani-suited women at their Catherine Deneuve Belle de Nuit best, board room by day and sexual consort by night and panhandlers who needed a dollar for a bed at the St. Nicholas men's shelter not two blocks away.
So, triage, an age-old system of ethical justification in which refusal of one simply meant caring for another.
India is a country which despite the economic vitality of the last few decades and the increasingly wealthy middle class, has extreme poverty; and any foreigner must develop some system of triage to keep an ethical balance and a clear conscience.
Some long-term residents simply shut their car windows, locked their doors, and looked ahead. Others gave only to the legless, armless children, pitifully malnourished and gasping babies.
Before visiting India, no visitor ever assumes there is a moral hierarchy to be assessed, judged, and addressed. What is the moral difference between a child with no arms and an adult with no legs, propelling himself between the traffic on a makeshift cart? Is blindness more deserving of alms than the desperately hungry? Where does the simply unfortunate fit?
Marfa at one point in her life thought that she would give a certain amount to specific charitable organizations to make life-or-death decisions for her. Dignity International was a well-known non-profit agency which ran soup kitchens, provided shelter and clothing for the needy; but there was a problem.
Much of the generous donations like those of Marfa Potter went into the hands of fund administrators. When discovered, the scam was on the level of the Minneapolis Learing Centers and Black Lives Matter, organizations which bilked the white middle class, set up offshore bank accounts, and provided nothing to their 'constituents'. Poverty was a going business. Lots of money was to be made.
So the idea of a moral intermediary dissolved with the spate of lawsuits against Dignity International. If she was to assuage the misery of the poorest of the poor, she would have to do it herself.
Yet, there seemed to be one trusted, secure, and vetted institution which was Constitutionally authorized to dispense aid to the Third World - to make a difference, to reduce mortality and morbidity, to provide schooling and child care.
That too turned out to be an airy fantasy; and before the Trump Administration closed down USAID, the State Department agency for development assistance, billions of taxpayer dollars had been diverted and stolen right under their noses.
Credulous American officials, hired to do good in the world and blind to the endemic corruption, moral diffidence, and blatant thievery at the highest levels in Africa kept renegotiating loans, reconfiguring grants - anything to help the poor, while savvy foreign bureaucrats stole the money as it poured in.
So, back to personal triage, sorting through the detritus of life and trying to make moral sense of it all; but the more she gave away her money, and the more she saw the same beneficiaries of her largesse implementing their own scams, orchestrating their begging according to market demand and demographics, the less she felt like giving.
Late last year (2025) the Washington Times did a series entitled, 'Streetcorner Begging - What Are The Poor Really Up To?' in which they exposed a large 'begging ring'. Streetcorner panhandlers were not working on their own but for others to whom they gave a generous cut to others who contributed enough to the Patrolman's Benevolent Fund to keep the police away from 'legitimate underground entrepreneurs'.
So, when Marfa read the series, she had to conclude that much of what she gave to poor Henry on Farragut Square went to his fat cat handlers. She had been conned.
All of which turned her around. Was charity - whether the official dole, government assistance, or individual handouts - simply one big con, keeping the poor locked in a cycle of dependence and entitlement?
‘Get a job!', once anathema to the left - the very idea that the needy should be forced to work simply to stay alive when public largesse was available was political perversion - made more sense now, after her long odyssey of giving.
'Given enough time, a liberal will always become conservative' was a common meme on the street. Once individuals assessed the causes of poverty and the different ways of treating it regardless of political currency, and made decisions based on proven experience, they would reject unaccountable charity and demand results, partnership, and repayment.
And so it was that Marfa first changed her downtown route to avoid the most congested tent cities, panhandlers, and homeless - a change which would afford her a modicum of ethical peace. Then she stopped giving to the seemingly able, those who could work for a living, and finally she gave up her personal charitable odyssey altogether.
Whether or not she became a Republican is unknown. It is rumored that she left Washington for Montana, Wyoming, or Idaho where there are few black people. Regrets for leaving the good Christian life of charity? Perhaps after a drink or two, but like most conservative converts, she said, 'Where have I been all these years?'.

.jpg)











