"Whenever I go into a restaurant, I order both a chicken and an egg to see which comes first"

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

F. Scott Fitzgerald, The Great Gatsby, And All Men - The Destructive Beauty Of First Love

F. Scott Fitzgerald wrote about first love, and famously in his short story, The Rich Boy, he said, 'There are many kinds of love in the world, but never the same love twice', a sentiment even more poignant, sad, and regretful in Winter Dreams. 

In Winter Dreams, the young boy Dexter Green falls in love with Judy Jones, a pert, sassy, and beautiful girl.  He pursues her for years, but she always refuses his offers to marry.  Discouraged but finally resigned he marries but unhappily.  He can never forget Judy Jones.  

When he meets her again, many years later, she is still unmarried - her own magical fantasies too wrapped in physical beauty but in a hopelessly selfish, arrogant mind. 

Dexter has been consumed by that particular capture of first love, and Judy trapped in impossibly romantic assumptions. 

The rich boy, Anson Hunter, is a character between the two.  He has a first love but is as demurring as Judy Jones in his assumption that someone even better will come along.  He ends up wandering the streets of New York, all his friends married and gone for the summer, and chatting with the bartender at they empty Yale Club. 

Randall Cobb was a Dexter Green.  When he met Deirdre Finch he was more than just smitten.  He was taken by a girl of enormous will, energy, and authority but balanced by an artistic subtlety and musical talent; and he was emotionally beholden to her from the very beginning. 

It was by no means a Lawrentian affair of dominance and submission - such sexual emotional and sexual equilibrium did not characterize their particular relationship - but there was still something about the girl which was unavoidable.  Once he knew her, he was no longer an agent.  He was complicit, engaged, and submissive. 

It is easy to misread the relationship. We have been so influenced by Freud that we cannot help looking for some exaggerated mother-love, deeply embedded incestuous feeling, or an infantile need for protection and cover; but all these assumptions would be far off the mark.  As Fitzgerald wrote, there is such a thing as love, especially first love, that simply overwhelms the natively romantic man. 

Jay Gatsby, the main character in Fitzgerald's The Great Gatsby, falls in love with Daisy Buchanan when he was a young man.  Daisy was his first love and in that short, intense, unforgettable period before he went off to war, she was permanently imprinted.  There would never be another like her.  Both he and Daisy vowed to marry when he returned from France; but she couldn't wait.  'Rich girls don't marry poor boys', she says and marries Tom Buchanan, fabulously wealthy, impressive, and strong. 

Gatsby doesn't marry.  The love he had and still has for Daisy makes marriage with anyone else impossible.  He becomes wealthy and builds a mansion across the bay from Daisy's home, signaled by a flashing green light on her dock that can be seen from his.  He makes no attempts to see her - the dream is enough, an exquisite nostalgia, a longing which if satisfied will extinguish it.  Yet when their paths do cross, they begin the love that both had thought lost. 

The story ends badly with Gatsby dead, murdered, and Daisy off to Europe with Tom without even a gesture of condolence or regret; but Fitzgerald's admiration for Gatsby is undimmed.  Nick Carroway, the narrator of the story says that Gatsby embodies all that he despised in a man, but in the end he was 'better than all of them', Daisy, Tom, and the hundreds of 'guests' who swarmed Gatsby's weekend parties, ate, drank, danced, and went home without a second thought. 

Randall Cobb should have known better or should have been warned about what happens when first love comes too early, without warning, and without reflective experience. The young first lover has no context in which to sort out unexpected feelings.  Older men with former lovers at least have some points of reference and can vet and suss and triage; but the young man has none of this. 

Cormac McCarthy, not a writer known for love interest, writes of the inescapable past - that series of random events which compel the present.  We are no more than billiard balls clattering in ways determined only by the direction, force, and spin of the cue ball.  We are who we are because we were determined to be that way - our genes, our parentage, the favors and insults of our environment, chance happenings, unexpected events are the only qualifying factors in our existence. 

This is how Fitzgerald qualifies first love - one does not have a choice - but where he adds to McCarthy is in the lifelong regret of loss.  The true nihilist accepts his fate and moves on.  McCarthy's most memorable character, Anton Chigurh in No Country for Old Men, is such a man.  He is an intelligent psychopath - one who has not an iota of compassion, respect, or affection, who kills at will with no regret or remorse.  Yet at the same time he is governed by an implacable moral code - the flip of the coin, the irreversible laws of chance which in a deterministic world is the only 'morality'. 

All this was incidental to the unhappiness of Randall Cobb who fell in love with Deirdre Finch, who gave her up, and regretted it forever.  He could never explain why he had been so taken with Deirdre and why from the very first had an emotional grasp, a pervasiveness and a permanence that had come unexpectedly.  His parents had an ordinary, complaisant marriage, but there was no unbordering love such as he had for Deirdre.  He was not particularly romantic, expectant, or overly optimistic; and so his love for Deirdre would always remain indecipherable. 

They married and were divorced only two years later - ironically a clue to the intensity of his love.  Deirdre was simply too passionate, too inventive, too ambitious, and too adventurous for what he now understood was a very traditional man.  Yet, even with this understanding, he could not forget her.  Their separation was not because of her, it was because of him. 

His following two marriages were desultory affairs compared to that brief interlude with Deirdre, satisfying up to a point, fillers more than anything, anodynes, and antipodes.  They were both practical, sensible, efficient, dutiful, and responsible women - good wives for most men, but not for Randall who, like Gatsby, was always looking for that flashing green light across the bay. 

Petrarch began the romantic potboiler and Hindus put a lid on it.  The chance that two individuals who randomly meet, fall in love, and marry will ever find some mystical magic in the relationship is zero.  Arranged marriage eliminates chance, probability, and disappointment.  Better to live life on an even keel, the mind free to explore the mysteries of God, than to suffer the ups and downs and hapless inconsistencies of marriage.  St. Paul could not have said it better. 


Romantic love dies hard, and first love never dies; but it remains as an annealing force in a disparate, complex, and unknowable world.  Romantic sentiment is at least a temporary, joyful, spirited bit in Hobbes' short, brutish, and nasty life.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.