Strindberg's play, The Father, is about a Victorian woman who refuses to accept the dictates of her patriarchal, arrogant husband. To gain complete control of their daughter and the family finances, she sows the seeds of doubt about the paternity of their daughter, thus slowly but surely rendering him mad. He has him committed, and she gains independent wealth and complete control of the family.
In the play the Captain has ruled his wife, Laura, for years and dictated all decisions about her, their home, and their daughter. When Laura feels that he has finally overstepped his bounds, making arbitrary decisions about their daughter and her education, she decides to refuse and force his hand. She does so with the psychological canniness and evil intent of Iago, introducing the idea, however subtlety that their daughter is not his.
She knows that paternity is at the heart of male jealousy and insecurity – men can never absolutely know whether the children borne by their wives are theirs – and she progressively suggests that their child might not be his. Such doubts, especially since they never can be proven, are by nature corrosive, and eventually the Captain goes mad. Laura commits him to a mental institution, and she takes charge of her daughter. Adding insult to injury she tells him, “Now you have fulfilled your function as an unfortunately necessary father…, you are not needed any longer and you must go.”
It is this notion that is behind jealousy. What king wants the next in line for the throne to be someone else's child? And what peasant, working from dawn to dusk just to provide for his family, wants to do so for someone else's children?
There is no more common human trait than jealousy. Shakespeare understood it perhaps better than most, and featured virulently jealous characters in Othello, The Winter’s Tale, Cymbeline, and Much Ado About Nothing. The men in these plays all have been duped, tricked, and deceived, and on the flimsiest of evidence have gone on to condemn their lovers and all women. Othello tells his judges about to sentence him for the murder of Desdemona that he did them and all men a favor ridding the city of yet one more lying slattern.
Claudio, lover of Hero, is taken in by the most transparent trickery of Don John who wants to avenge Claudio’s military victory. He arranges for a mock balcony scene where imposters play Hero and her lover and their exchange is to be overheard and relayed to Claudio. Claudio takes this contrived hearsay for fact, and launches a virulent attack on the unfaithful Hero and on all women. Even Leonato, Hero’s father is quick to judgment and assuming guilt condemns his daughter.
Posthumus in Cymbeline is taken in by Iachimo, and in one of Shakespeare’s most violently misogynistic passages, condemns his wife as a treacherous vixen. The men, fathers and sons, in The Winter’s Tale are no different. Hearsay added to innuendo and jealous suspicion throws the sweet, innocent Perdita’s character into disrepute.
Marcel Proust was perhaps the most eloquent about jealousy:
It is not even necessary for that person to have attracted us, up till then, more than or even as much as others. All that was needed was that our predilection should become exclusive. And that condition is fulfilled when – in this moment of deprivation – the quest for the pleasures we enjoyed in his or her company is suddenly replaced by an anxious, torturing need, whose object is the person alone, an absurd, irrational need which the laws of this world make it impossible to satisfy and difficult to assuage – the insensate agonizing need to possess exclusively.
Vladimir Nabokov was equally compelling about jealousy, and in the final scenes of Lolita Humbert has Claire Quilty read this poem:
Because you stole her
from her wax-browed and dignified protector
spitting into his heavy-lidded eye
ripping his flavid toga and at dawn
leaving the hog to roll upon his new discomfort
the awfulness of love and violets
remorse despair while you
took a dull doll to pieces
and threw its head away
because of all you did
because of all I did not
you have to die
The Saudis have explicitly said what all men have been thinking all along - the only way to assure fidelity and the paternity of your children is to lock women up. Harsh, punitive, abusive? Not in the mind of Saudi men who simply face facts. You can never be sure of the paternity of your child unless the women has absolutely no access to other men. Lock and key. Always in the company of a male relative; and even then covered from head to toe.
Feminists have every right to condemn Saudi society, but not for the reasons they claim. It is not because of women's treatment at the hands of men, it is because they have been robbed of their power; for the power of paternity is women's ultimate weapon.
Maud Harris tried to keep her husband, Berkeley on a short leash because he had been a wanderer, a man who took seriously his Biblical birthright to go forth and multiply. Maud had done nothing more than huff and puff when he came in from 'working late at the office'. She ignored all the tell-tale signs of infidelity, for like most women the sunken costs were simply too big to be cancelled. Yet her husband's adultery had gotten too much to bear. He had gotten too big for his britches, came and went as though the marriage contract meant nothing; and so it was time to act.
The Harrises had two young children, all of whom - though theirs - shared no resemblance with their father. They were all Blantons - her family - with the same aquiline nose, thinnish lips, and narrow-set eyes. They could have used some of the Harris family genes, a generally handsome, well-cut breed, the Mendelian luck of the draw was such that their genetic lineage was unilateral.
In the Shakespeare play, Cymbeline In Cymbeline, King Cymbeline is concerned that his legitimate son, Arvirargus, may not be his biological child. This suspicion arises because Arvirargus was kidnapped in infancy by the exiled lord Belarius and raised as Belarius’s son, Polydore. Cymbeline studies his son's face for resemblance, but already convinced of his wife's infidelity finds none.
In The Winter’s Tale Leontes also wonders about the paternity of his son Mamillius. This doubt fuels his descent into irrational jealousy. Although the boy looks exactly like Leontes, he suspects that Hermione might be lying about their resemblance.
Maud did not have to read Shakespeare or Strindberg to know what to do. She was a canny, determined woman who knew men's fundamental, innate, biological weakness - jealousy and its origin, paternity; and so it was that like the greatest moral thieve of literature, Iago, she began to sow doubt in her husband's mind about his fatherhood. She did his slowly, carefully, progressively, and surely.
She never addressed the question directly, only alluded to men in her life she knew around the time of her pregnancies. More than Berkeley wanted to know, since he had always seen that his wife was, despite the family genes, a very beautiful woman. Add that to women's natural tendency to stray (Othello tells his judges that he, by killing Desdemona, a duplicitous, deceitful woman, has done all men a favor), and Berkeley was caught in his wife's trap.
Now, she knew that questioning the paternity of their children would not directly stop his adultery, but it would do so indirectly for he would now pay more attention to her, still in her fertile, reproductive years.
What she did not count on was her husband's damaged psyche and although such doubts addled the mind of The Captain in the Strindberg play, it enrages most men who become hostile and punitive. Hilary Mantel in Eight Months on Ghazzah Street tells the story of how her European husband becomes more and more like his Saudi colleagues and more understanding of their measures to control their wives.
So Berkeley did not take all these innuendoes and asides well, and began to assume the worst. He became questioning, accusatory, mean, and intolerant. This was not 'paying more attention to me' meant at all.
Out of pique, insult, and misogyny, she decided to make good on the age-old premise - the duplicity of the female - and before the end of the school year was involved with a younger man, also married, also feeling his entitlement and with no moral strings attached. It was a passionate affair - one in which she secretly wanted to get pregnant and give substance to the millennia-old assumptions about women, throw reality in the face of suspicion.
And when she did get pregnant - either by her husband or her lover - and her husband found about the affair, he went completely berserk, as demented and lunatic as The Captain. As a result, she was able to sue for divorce and a handsome settlement, kept the children, and went on to marry again.
She was under no illusions about the men's birthright argument, but was prepared. The second time around would be a charm.




No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.